| Author |
|
hellion19
Forum Warrior
Joined: 01 Aug 2012
Status: Offline
Points: 310
|
Posted: 26 Oct 2012 at 17:00 |
|
Lots of the OP's post just is the opinion that they feel the war is and then turning it into what he wants to portray as insider knowledge.
Like I could say that I have insider knowledge and that this was a badly thought out plan that Consone would use SkB as a non consone member to push RHY into joining Consone. After the conflict between SkB happened they can send ABSA in and if ABSA can't win it then send in VIC. Perhaps this plan simply backfired when H? joined in and all the way upto the point that H? did join in they seemed fine with the war.
Seems about as legit as the OP.
|
 |
glorfindel
Wordsmith
Joined: 02 Sep 2011
Status: Offline
Points: 129
|
Posted: 26 Oct 2012 at 15:23 |
LionArse wrote:
Well. The current sad state of affairs in beautiful Illyriad has reached the point where I feel no choice but to wade in to the cesspool that passes for a great deal of posts on this forum. Most of the posts are of the following types: pedantic, bravado, spin, ego stroking (both self and of others), inability to refrain from seeking attention, self-serving, attempts to troll one party or the other, and outright lies . . . I can and will simply tell you what this war is, at least at the beginning before the vultures and opportunists became involved.
|
You can now add "didactic" to your own list, as your post fills that category nicely.
|
 |
Ossian
Forum Warrior
Joined: 12 Oct 2010
Status: Offline
Points: 456
|
Posted: 26 Oct 2012 at 12:08 |
JimJams wrote:
Lion... |
...south end of a horse travelling north.
Established players from both sides of the H?/Consone divide will recognise that this player only ever appears to create discord at times like these. In this particular thread he seems to want to invoke bitter critcism of H?, Consone and almost every player that will comment on this issue.
I hope that ,ironically, his reappearance will cause H? to realise that there is no one in Consone who can be compared to Lionz for his irresponsible and negative attempts to manipulate the game. Jasche is not Lionz ( or Diabilto for that matter) as Consone is not White.
The reappearance of Lionz only serves to remind us that H? et al and Consone have much more in common than those who seek to promote bullying and trollish behaviour.
I hope his reappearance will cause both sides to look at at each other anew and realise the positive contributions that they have brought to the community in times of peace. The sooner we end this conflict the better
|
 |
Myzel
Wordsmith
Joined: 19 Feb 2012
Status: Offline
Points: 101
|
Posted: 26 Oct 2012 at 10:22 |
Hadus wrote:
I wish to challenge your belief that H? is to be admonished
for lies and subversion. How can you admire and respect a plan to
destroy a perceived rival using surprise and hidden motives, and then
accuse them for the very tactics which they required to carry out their
plan?
Simply put, manipulation of facts is part of war. This
isn't a duel; there is no honor to be won if you end up face down in a
ditch. If deceit and lies are one path to victory, does it make any
sense o remove that option on moral grounds, especially when there is no
guarantee your opponent won't do the same?
|
You make a good point but it doesn't mean someone can't both
admire and admonish H?'s game. Deception can be part of war and I could
admire skillful use of it. I think RHY/H?'s feigned interest in peace
talks on the condition that VIC would stop breaking sieges was a stroke
of genius, really. But I think that it is still a game that can be
played with integrity (which, in fact, is a good strategy because other players respect it). Much of H? game has been tainted by namecalling, ridiculing and hateful accusations (although I'm not saying
they were the only ones to do it - players from the Consone side or
neutral flamers have been doing it as well). I morally can't respect
that. And when you think about it, much of the truth-twisting was done in such a half-assed way that hardly anyone actually ate it up. So even from a
purely strategic standpoint, I wouldn't respect this part of their game
because it wasn't skillful or subtle and only served to make themselves
look bad. All in all I'd say H?'s plan was interesting. Its execution had its moments, but was a little too obvious which made the falsehoods all the more blatant. Of course, the game isn't over yet. Maybe they'll have something up their sleeve.
Edited by Myzel - 26 Oct 2012 at 10:44
|
 |
Thes Hunter
Wordsmith
Joined: 13 Jul 2012
Status: Offline
Points: 129
|
Posted: 26 Oct 2012 at 02:41 |
|
Nice Bob Geldof look there JimJams.
|
The image in my avatar is a chalk pastel drawing I did as part of the Imagine Yellowstone Art competition.
|
 |
JimJams
Forum Warrior
Joined: 20 Sep 2011
Location: Italy
Status: Offline
Points: 496
|
Posted: 26 Oct 2012 at 00:57 |
|
Lion...
|
|
|
 |
Loud Whispers
Wordsmith
Joined: 31 Jul 2012
Location: Saltmines
Status: Offline
Points: 196
|
Posted: 26 Oct 2012 at 00:46 |
Hadus wrote:
There is only thing we can be certain of: at the end of this war, the story that will be considered "correct" is the one told by the winner. It's been that way in real life since the beginning of recorded history, and it will be no different here.
|
Since recorded history - when information could be suppressed. Whoever wins, the other side's arguments, propaganda and insights will still float around in the forums and with the people who sided with them. A minor detail, but I think this is just too large with too many people listening for it to die down like that.
|
 |
dunnoob
Postmaster
Joined: 10 Dec 2011
Location: Elijal
Status: Offline
Points: 800
|
Posted: 26 Oct 2012 at 00:26 |
gameplayer wrote:
a few ego trips ruin a whole tournament for the rest of the people in illy |
Alliance tournaments can be fun for players in the alliances on page one, for most other players they are rather boring. If 11 of the top 20 alliances get into a war distracting them from this tournament it is actually good for some smaller alliances, who would be otherwise squeezed out by H?, VIC, and so on.
|
 |
Hadus
Postmaster
Joined: 28 Jun 2012
Status: Offline
Points: 545
|
Posted: 26 Oct 2012 at 00:26 |
|
I wish to challenge your belief that H? is to be admonished for lies and subversion. How can you admire and respect a plan to destroy a perceived rival using surprise and hidden motives, and then accuse them for the very tactics which they required to carry out their plan?
Simply put, manipulation of facts is part of war. This isn't a duel; there is no honor to be won if you end up face down in a ditch. If deceit and lies are one path to victory, does it make any sense o remove that option on moral grounds, especially when there is no guarantee your opponent won't do the same?
There is only thing we can be certain of: at the end of this war, the story that will be considered "correct" is the one told by the winner. It's been that way in real life since the beginning of recorded history, and it will be no different here.
|
|
|
 |
twilights
Postmaster
Joined: 21 May 2012
Status: Offline
Points: 915
|
Posted: 25 Oct 2012 at 23:37 |
|
the only i know is that a few ego trips ruin a whole tournament for the rest of the people in illy, i dont know how the others feel but i was dragged into this war as well as alot of other people by secret backstabbing dealings, but that seems the way that illy is going, the current leadership of several of the alliances involved is to look out for their own egos first instead of the good of their membership. there are so many people that were caught up in this war that should not be in it and of course these ego character leaders just make rules saying they will not attack anyone small and gosh they will only take 30 percent of strength of a person, or some such garbage. what they dont realize that many of the lesser players change playing styles for the war and what a disruption this is to those players. i say its time to speak up to these egos and tell them to form an alliance like the members of nc did and fight their so call wars out and leave the rest of us people out of their so call wars....and those being attacked there is no way to win, just give it up...and lets all thank these leaders for us losing the chance of playing an illy wide tournament..u call yourself leaders of the game, then u should respect it, poor job to all leaders involved, especially those with all their secret ways and dealings...oh by the way i went into the safety of a trainning alliance, i hope u rspect that... and tell my bf he better take me out saturday and not play this dumb war....im still mad at him for last weekend...dance dance...i love justin bieber!
|
 |