I must admit... I have been enjoying the silent/steadfast accounts (even though they caused me confusion in GC with the initials "SS"). I only jumped to conclusions (aka: played the devils advocate) due to my complete and utter shock that one of them had suddenly been suspended. I once played a game where long-standing, well known players being suspended meant that they were breaking rules - it was never voluntary.
However, the scenarios of meta-gaming by multiple accounting solely for the purpose of farming your own cities is frowned upon, so I rather feel karpintero should be less narrow-minded and possibly look at the overall picture before smearing others.
Now if he had smeared Ryelle, that would be another story altogether... *she is, after all, the evil one*